How can you attack a positional area if it is just a piece of terrain? Is the field attacked? :-)

Yeah, first it annexed Crimea, then the war began. Girkin came from Russia with his brothers, equipment, weapons, people, lost paratroopers - they will not

This article needs to be sent to foreign media, and let them be glad that they have defeated the Russians again, but we don't need it

Well, NATO troops always celebrate victory when they hit the range of our missiles, and the radars were turned off at that time :)

They allowed and attacked.

The ship is in the center of the Black Sea, and you forgot about the line-of-sight range, the height of the ship is not 1000 m, but what the level of interference should be in order to hammer the receivers of all C 400s along the side lobes of the radiation pattern in obstruction mode

Are there Russian computers?

So Hacked or Broken Hacked?

But with new missiles and guidance systems

Hello! Who knows French well - tell them that they are not going to create a museum of foreign ships in our country. Thank.

So was the attack or not .. disabled our equipment or not .. so many opinions! Article - was it created from scratch?))

Tell strangers that our country is not going to create a museum of foreign ships.

The author did not study well and does not know the basics of radar. It is not the carrier frequency of the radar that is important, but the algorithm for its rebuilding. And this code is comparable to a cipher machine. Therefore, the S-400 was sold to the Turks without any damage.

And why did not Putin please you?

Estonia lost its missile on the territory of the Russian Federation. then the NATO ship conducts reconnaissance on our territory - sheer coincidences!

It is unlikely that any country can compete with Russia in the operation of electronic warfare systems.

France, ships, this is NATO. NATO is the United States.

Exactly!

Perhaps they know purity, but no frequency! Moreover, they quickly serena the tram.

So you can do that?))) Hello NATO!

and you know what followed after pearl harbor, let me remind you of herasim and nagasaki

Aftorr has no idea about the principles of the combat use of air defense systems. You don't have to comment further.

Isn't it time for the Crimean "Bastions" to conduct training firing at a real target, and not at a standing target? ...

The author is called listening to the ringing, but I don't know where he is. It is impossible to completely drown the range at such distances, it takes less than a minute to rebuild it. Yes, and there is more than one radar, there is a whole complex of them for different bands. L range (decimeter) and VHF w / h. If the C400 works as a complex of radars, the French trough will not have a chance ...

This applies only to certain types of vehicles in open combat. And that is very conditional. I just needed some kind of figure for the calculation.

An attempt at attack means radio-electronic (setting of active and passive interference, for example), i.e. all frequencies at which the radar is operating are clogged with stupidly high power.

Turkey has an export option. There are other parameters.

What are you, right?
You take a caliper and measure the dimensions of the waveguide from the ZIP. So much for the carrier frequency of the tracking station

But in general, the frequencies of the stations are written in the forms. And if suddenly for some reason they didn't write it, then it can be measured

How interesting ... but nothing that someone sold the S-400 division to Turkey and that Turkey is a NATO member and, within the framework of existing agreements, provided information about the carrier frequencies and other parameters of the complex to the allies, including France?

Another delirium of the author ... The frequency of the S-400 can be changed. Turkish S-400s have different specifications.

for especially smart and not very attentive - the export version of the S-400 is significantly different from ours, and it is impossible to hack and study it.

The finger is on the trigger, and the trigger is something else

What can you know about Stalin and human rights? Your remarks immediately catch the eye of an inadequate zombie by Putin's zombie box. Even with no one to enter into polemics, it is clear that it is useless.

Air defense systems are activated regardless of the nationality of the aircraft or the gender of the crew members ...

It is interesting how many times during this time the Frenchman was "attacked" by both our submarines and surface ships, as well as aviation and coastal batteries. So in real life it is not known how much he would sail if he tried to attack our S-400.

Air defense systems are activated regardless of the nationality of the aircraft or the gender of the crew members ...

It's more convenient to arrange Pearl Harbor from the sofa ...

Wash our purity is not a secret for anyone

And my comments are so truthful that the censorship on the site does not allow them to pass, although censorship is prohibited by the Constitution of the Russian Federation .......

Absolutely right, to the point!

The French, did they whisper to the author about frequency interception ...?, Do not write nonsense.

waveguides thing narrowband

I agree completely, or introduced paid comments)))

No

Production of the S-400 began in 1987. 33 years ago. Another would have remembered the PPSh machine gun.

And what prevents ours from changing the frequency of the radar. As far as I remember, this is the basis of the work of air defense systems in real hostilities, otherwise the guaranteed destruction that ours in the times of sobscha and lelali, when there was an Arab Israeli war

Any combat unit "lives" for 15 minutes. This is in the mid 80s of the last century

We still need to sell the s-500 to Turkey ...

Americans can buy a Russian computer, but not the fact that they will be able to beat Russian computers at chess. It's not a tricky business to muddy water. Chip to see in troubled water !!!

I just want to ask: "What could have been done like that?" Where is the Black Sea Fleet, where is the Air Force and Air Defense, which admitted that a foreign ship walks with impunity on our shores?

In the Soviet Union, there was a 159th Brigade of reconnaissance ships of the Northern Fleet, Russia no longer needed such a Brigade of ships and was disbanded, on the Internet you can see the sunken ships. And the enemy is all right and the article confirms this.

And we work for rubles and there is more than enough patriotism, especially when there is nothing to pay for the mortgage and the wife is pregnant alone at home.

I suspect that the S-400 is no longer in Crimea. There is something new.

Or maybe it would be better to start with the Hawaiian tradition - to remind them of Pearl Harbor, so that they would never forget.

Let me ask. Is it true that modern equipment only operates at one frequency?

Our president serves, but it is not known about yours.

After reading the title, you don't have to read any further! ..)))

Where are you from? We have a PRESIDENT. In Russia. And you probably have a president? And, probably, the people?

Yes, it can be delivered both on the ground and by plane.

Poor, the little head is flowing. Hacked the system of democracy ??? Destroyed human rights ??? You made me laugh. Run Lola Run !!!! It may not be too late to go to the doctors for the mexturka

Where is the electronic warfare? Burn down the radar onboard let it wander the Black Sea until the grub ends

First, the rights of a citizen must be ensured, and then only human rights. The army is needed to protect the rights of a citizen!

Yes, thanks to the citizen president (who sold the NATO member S-400) ??????? they probably already know all the characteristics, and now they are training! Therefore, there is nothing to be surprised at. There is only one question: does our president actually serve someone, his people or his relatives, it seems, partners?

So what ??? This is a common normal thing.
Who does not allow our people to do something like this off the coast of France or England with Spain, the USA or Italy ??? Do it. And the more often the better.

Yeah, we'll throw our hats.

And what are we ashamed of? More provocations and not only around the USA, but also from France :)

Empty it. Shooting rules teach us that it is the initiators of active jamming that are destroyed first. How long does a ship, locked in the Black Sea, live?
Such actions reveal vulnerabilities in the complexes and help to eliminate them. And there are always spare frequencies.

It is necessary to drink less kvass and watch TV.
S-400 complexes were sold to a NATO member country. What else is there to learn?
This is an export product.

As I understand it, the S-400 radar is turned on only if the complex is actually used. In other cases, survey locators work, the data of which, I believe, are not poorly known. Well, to force the use of the S-400 on a target - this is hardly included in the plans of the adversaries, and as the previous experience of NATO ships entering the Black Sea shows, their servicemen work exclusively for dollars, they do not smell of patriotism, and therefore they are very cowardly. ..

Hey, analysts, or whatever, why should the radars of the air and missile defense system be activated in connection with the entry of a French ship into the Black Sea?

As a former air defense officer, you probably know that the S-400 systems have been sold to Turkey, a NATO member, which is also France. This means that the frequency range in which the S-400 operates is known to the French. This implies that it is in this range that interference is placed that interfere with the operation of the radio receivers of the complex.

An article from a person who absolutely does not understand the topic into which he stuck. If it were so easy to interfere, then air defense systems would be useless. Especially for the afftor, air defense systems do not operate at the same frequency, and these frequencies change. It is simply impossible to jam across the entire frequency range.

And it is not necessary. Personally, I believe. I believe that all the nasty things from Europe and the United States. While they poke their noses into the affairs of others, they need to be kept at gunpoint with a trigger finger. And I hope that the bitter experience when our victories come through great sacrifices will not be repeated.

Probably the same reasoning when Germany attacked the USSR, Stalin did not even create an appearance about human rights. And let's so, human rights are relatively respected if these are not electoral rights))

The only ones who will help you cope with your “believe / don’t / believe” are the orderlies ... They will give you a rubber saber and a cardboard shield to protect the system of democracy from hacking and pinpoint attacks on your ... rights. Hold on there ... And have a good mood ... And be more careful with drugs in the future ... Addiction may come ...

Have you already prepared the flags of the European Union?

Arguing with provocateurs is a waste of time. If they introduced compulsory registration on various discussion platforms, so that one could immediately see who is hiding behind a nickname, and from where, then the number of provocations on the Internet would decrease.
And you can read everything, but you cannot believe everything.

In response, it is necessary to check the air defense radars in Alaska or in the Caribbean - to comb it

I am competent, I will not say anything)) state secrets and treason are very close.

And you're doing the right thing. You do not need to believe OUR President, believe your own (Poroshenko, etc.).

Let them just stick around. Let's get the checkers and "Attack with steel rows ..."

"Such actions on the part of France are possible only in the case of intercepting radio frequencies emitted by the S-400 radar," who wrote that, what kind of theorem is this? Did you go to school in general, or did you play games on your father's computer?

What created confidence in NATO and France?

Good day. Here is the first adequate comment. Thank.

I read the comments. Opinions are of course different, and that's good! The main thing is that the military will not let you down, the border is locked, and the inhabitants of Russia can sleep peacefully!

As far as I understand, Roman belongs to the "bulk" squad and, besides, he is absolutely ignorant technically.

Unbelieving "Thomas". You not only do not believe Putin, but you despise your Motherland, Russia.

Do not forget to hang your flags, otherwise no one will believe

Roman, you are a free person, and if you are scared and uncomfortable, you can leave for another country, where there is more democracy, and where the police are not beating. To live there and be happy, why sit in a burrow and are afraid of everything, so you can bring yourself to a nervous breakdown, and there is a psychiatric hospital or even worse. Look for a comfortable place to live, and live peacefully and happily.

It is a pity that those competent in this field do not write practically anything, but amateurs and provocateurs do not subside and mislead readers.

What does democracy in Russia and Putin in the Kremlin have to do with these events with the ship of France, the USA and NATO are behaving aggressively towards Russia in accordance with the plans developed by the same USA. American troops are at our borders and you support this? If you are a citizen of Russia, then your words are criminal before the state and the people of this state.I would, having the power of such novels, deprive them of citizenship by giving them the opportunity to say nasty things on the other side of the border

Apparently you, Roman, are from Ukraine.

Such provocations can lead to an adequate response and maybe to war .. this is a solution to the issue ..

Fly to France and join the yellow jellies. Also visit Portland in the USA. at the same time you will see what kind of democracy an exceptional nation has. Maybe they'll give you life. There will be time to remember how you were beaten in Russia.

Let me ask a specialist: So why do ours then allow the "French electronic trough" to stand under our noses and collect (probe) our frequency ranges ??? They took, as you say, and removed their electronics by means of electronic warfare

Most likely you hacked yourself. And democracy does not exist. All this is the invention of the almighty.

Alexander, it's even funnier to read the fantasies of a former air defense officer, how electronic warfare means burn out the enemy's electronics when trying to listen to frequencies.

Where did you find in Putin's article? About NATO, your own business. You can even contribute 2% annually from the family budget. Maybe they will protect you from the police

don't believe it)) .. everyone has their own truth .. and stupidity))

The author decided to pour balm on his wounds ... He smiled.

"I can't believe my eyes, have you really come?" Eyes and ears, poor fellow. Maybe then faith will appear

I wonder how, when listening to the air with a receiver, you will determine who is listening to you and on what frequency?

What rights do you personally have Roman destroyed by Putin?

the opinion of the novel, with a small letter, is very important, thanks.

What are your rights violated? When did the police beat you? What does the belief in NATO have to do with it?

and let them try - extra training, and the king - the rules !!!!!!

An illiterate article for housewives! Impossible to hack a radar is not a computer

How can you hack something that was not in Russia? Don't fantasize, dear.

And how the reb destroys the enemy's electronics, they can only give a hindrance to the air. But physically how?

What kind of democracy are you talking about? It was not in Russia and it will not be

If you believe NATO that they are good, and Putin is bad, then it's time for you to rush to France for permanent residence. And I feel good in Russia, no one oppresses me.

I wonder why you are not logging yet ?!

And what is this unbelieving boy doing here?

Continue in the same spirit. Obviously, you are already being transported dollars from the United States for "active anti-state struggle with your own country"

Put your distrust of Putin, along with your tongue, into your stinking ass, you hohlyaty idiot. Your faith in NATO is absolutely nothing after all the crimes of this shameful organization, and above all after Yugoslavia and Libya.

Then France will cry. We don't hit the little ones!

Why do people like you (and you including) need the police? You, my friend, have delusions of grandeur. And the caravan went on and will go on. And on the barking mongrels with megalomania, he somehow does not care.

Have you been beaten by the police yet? Do you believe that ours will beat you, and the police will just threaten the elves with a finger and, like a feeble-minded person, say: Nizza, ata-ta?)))) The system of democracy is such a system that in France I have been demanding yellow vests for two years, they demand put a bolt .... Or in the USA - .... well, you know about those who are not there.))) Clown - at least he raised his spirits. Laughed)))

Roman, so what are you doing in Russia, if you do not believe in your country, then you have to go there ... where you believe

Come to us in France and have FREEDOM and rights. You have more of them in Russia than we do. Power is the same everywhere.

So even his own bots do not trust him, who are drowning for him here, complaining that he constantly throws them for money.

You also believe in Hitler.

Who cares what you think?

Go to the stronghold of democracy, ukraine.
You will be safe there.
Faster before it's too late

I believe in NATO and France, and I do not believe in the Kremlin and Putin. My mistrust was created by Putin himself - he hacked the system of democracy in Russia and destroyed human rights with targeted strikes. And I know that if I believe him, the police will beat me up. So I don’t believe it.

Erm .... Are the authors of the text aware of how radars generally work? Are you aware of the grid phases? There is only one way to hack the radar — by physical access to the equipment. The specified ship can only try to collect "raw" information, which includes absolutely all noise. And it's not a fact that they will detect the real frequencies of the radar at all - for this they need information from the "physical" part. It's like trying to listen to a US standard walkie-talkie RF standard walkie talkie. To listen, you need to know the frequencies. And even more for the radar.

I am laughing ! read this lime as a former military air defense officer - every day the frequencies change and besides, our electronic warfare, when trying to listen to frequencies, destroy the enemy's electronics

Sheer nonsense. Our clever heads made it so that they were quickly declassified. Don't lie, I believe our military and scientists do not need gossip.

It is strange, why use an air defense system for a ship located in the middle of the Black Sea? There are completely different systems of destruction.

and that there are no jammers on the Black Sea coast to suppress the entire electronic part of the ship?